The Return of the Soldier – Rebecca West

Chris Baldry returns from the front to the three women who love him. His wife, Kitty, with her cold, moonlight beauty, and his devoted cousin Jenny wait in their exquisite home on the crest of the Harrow-weald. Margaret Allington, his first and long-forgotten love, is nearby in the dreary suburb of Wealdstone. But Chris is shell-shocked and can only remember the Margaret he loved fifteen years before, when he was a young man and she an inn-keeper’s daughter. His cousin he remembers only as a childhood playmate; his wife he remembers not at all. The women have a choice – to leave him where he wishes to be, or to ‘cure’ him. It is Margaret who reveals a love so great that she can make the final sacrifice

Noticing that nibbled apple on the cover, I gravitated to not only to the Virago logo but more importantly to the author’s name.  Having read some of West’s non-fiction pieces, mainly to do with religion and politics, her fiction promised to be a worthwhile read.

I didn’t enjoy this book as much as I hoped, although there were some aspects of the work that interested me.  Thankfully being one hundred and thirty-eight pages long (or short depending on your point of view), I was able to finish it before my patience was thoroughly worn out but it did take some effort to get to the end of this one, even with that in mind.

The story is focused on exploring the emotional impact of the three women, none of whom I really connected with.  Margaret is by far the most likeable character, whilst Kitty and Jenny came across as unbelievably snobby and at times ridiculously hysterical.  It was this overly dramatic nature that made me care little, despite appreciating the situation they were in.

The attitudes of the time – and class – are understandable, and the superficial does often mask deeper concerns and vulnerabilities but added to that was the way the story was written, it just left me cold.  It all feels very dated and lacked any sort of impact.

There were some parts of the book I valued, although perhaps there was not enough of them.  I liked the examination of the women at home waiting for news of the men, and how they chose to cope with not knowing. The solace taken in the natural world and in memories, which are both delicate and insubstantial at times, was a clever juxtaposition with Chris and being at the Front.

The question of whether it is better for Chris to be cured and remember both the good and the bad times, or to be left blissfully unaware of the war and all its terrors, is well done. I would have liked to have read more about Chris’ thoughts, and his take on the missing fifteen years.

The Return of the Soldier is a story about sacrifices in war and in life.  The book is, on reflection, an important one but it that didn’t focus on the bits I found most interesting and so, for me, feels like a bit of a missed opportunity in terms of rounding out the story and adding some flesh to Chris’ character, as well as the overall themes and emotional impact.

15 Replies to “The Return of the Soldier – Rebecca West”

  1. Disappointing when a book doesn’t meet your expectations. And it is definitely a difficult read when you cannot connect with the characters.


    1. Had the rich women not been so off putting I really could have enjoyed this book, but it was good to try something different.


  2. Yes, I’ve heard of Rebecca West before, but you have the advantage of me here in that I’ve never actually read anything of hers. Were there any battlefield flashback scenes, and if so, how well were they done?


    1. There wasn’t much in the way of mentions of battlefield scenes. There was a brief mention of things but it wasn’t in a flashback it was through the eyes of the women back home so nothing as visceral as one could expect to find in other books.


  3. An interesting review, SteJ. I read this ages ago, probably 25 years ago and remember quite enjoying it. It is definitely a “woman’s” book, isn’t it, with Chris as the token man returning from the war. I agree, it would have been a greater book if Chris’s story and character had been developed more but then this story does show how limited women’s lives were at the time and how little they really knew of the lives and experiences of the men they loved, and on whom they depended. The richer women do appear petty and hysterical but they had never conceived that Chris would come back so changed and that their lives would be so different from what they had had before the war.


    1. You make a good point about their limited lives, although I think even in their own world they are ridiculously insulated to the point of being offended by other people’s clothes. It all added up to me having little sympathy for them. I would have liked to see how they reacted to Chris’ experiences, that would have been such an interesting read.


  4. Keep reading and reviewing, Ste J.
    I might be guilty of liking your reviews, more than books. Yet, there are reviews, such as One hundred Years Of Solitude, when you remind me of the joy of reading.


    1. Well I will keep reviewing to remind you. It can be hard to get back into reading, especially as I know how little time you have. I have so many drafts that need to be completed. If I had a full day in solitude I can only imagine how prolific I could be!

      Liked by 1 person

Share your thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.